CONSIDERATIONS WHEN CHOOSING AN EMS PARTNER
Size and Alignment
When choosing a manufacturing partner, for a long term successful relationship, one of the most important considerations is choosing a supplier of proper size as compared to your annual purchase expenditure.
Tier 1&2 EMS’s generally service large Companies such as Microsoft, Apple, HP, Intel, and other large customers. Thus they will tailor and/or shift their engineering and manufacturing resources resulting in these customers receiving the majority of attention, support, and available resources as required. Due to this, smaller customers often experience lack of timely design & engineering support, production interruptions, delivery delays, or unexplainable price increases.
To help avoid this kind of situation you should try and align with a supplier where your annual expenditure, for the specific product, is approximately 20% of the supplier’s total sales volume, and preferably not less than 5%. In this way you have a much better chance that your projects will receive adequate attention and customer service.
Also important is consideration and evaluation of current market conditions in the supplier’s country or region. Asia, and especially China, is currently experiencing a declining economy and as a result manufacturing companies throughout Asia, in all market segments, are targeting smaller accounts to fill their available manufacturing capacity. It is common in a down market to receive very aggressive pricing as an enticement; however as the market rebounds and their larger customers increase demand, you as a smaller account will likely experience increased delays and price increases.
Lastly, but equally important, is making sure the supplier is not engaged in producing a competing product putting your intellectual property at risk of loss to a competitor.
Engineering Support
Equally critical to the success of your products is adequate project dedicated design and engineering support. In all likelihood you won’t have the resources to assign your engineers to the supplier’s manufacturing facility. As a less expense option, it would be preferable to choose a supplier that has either domestic engineering support, or is willing to place their engineers at your facility to assist your product designers and engineering staff.
Domestic engineering support, being the preferred choice, can help to ensure:
- Better control and protection of your designs and intellectual property reducing the chance of piracy or cross pollination to competitors.
- Reduced miscommunications and mistakes in regards to your needs and requirements.
- Immediate response to your inquiries, engineering changes, and requirements.
- Dedicated attention to your product – improving time to market.
- Quicker turn-times for prototyping and pre-production builds.
- Early DFM reviews to ensure manufacturing efficiency, product quality and performance, and potential cost reductions.>
- Elimination of issues with time zone differences.
- Possession of designs for ability to change suppliers if the need should arise.
Quality Assurance & Supplier Certifications
When choosing a supplier it should be mandatory that they are ISO quality certified. However, ISO certification does not alone guarantee the supplier’s quality or that their processes are actually in control. Before engaging you should have a qualified person perform a process audit that includes, but not limited to, a review of their ISO audit history for infractions, evidence of SPC (statistical process controls), TQM (total quality
management) programs exist, and examination of final test and inspection records to determine 1st pass yields.
Inspection Plans
You should require the chosen supplier to develop, with your input, a detailed quality assurance plan tailored to your specific product. This plan should include, but not limited to, random verification testing of raw materials, in process inspection or testing verification of key components and sub assemblies, product operational/functional testing, cosmetic inspections, etc.
In-Process Inspections
In-process inspections should be part of your quality plan and be performed regularly by an independent QA person, either employed or compensated by you, that is has full understanding and knowledge of your particular product and will provide you with unbiased reports for any issues discovered. In the event a quality issue is discovered, and if necessary, this person should have full authority to stop a production line and quarantine defective product until an adequate resolution is determined and implemented. Then most important ensure that a corrective action is put in place and monitored to ensure elimination of the issue.
Adherence to Specifications and Approved Materials
Unless there is strict adherence to process control, unauthorized material substitutions or changes in processes, in an effort to reduce costs, can be made by the supplier without your approval. Unless you are informed prior to, and adequately evaluate and test the results, the change may cause quality or performance problems that are not detectable until after the product has been released to the market. Obviously the cost of a product recall and the damage to your name brand can be disastrous. This scenario can only be effectively detected and eliminated by regular in-process inspections by a dedicated and qualified inspector.
Testing and Verification
As part of your quality assurance plan, it is critical to also perform in-process testing, such as ICT (In Circuit Testing) of your PCBA assemblies and followed with a final Functional Product Test and verification.
Payment and Risk of Loss
Most off-shore Tier 1&2 EMS companies require an LC (Irrevocable Letter of Credit) whereby upon shipment from the supplier’s facility or port of departure, the supplier receives full payment and the goods become your property and responsibility. Unless you have inspection personnel, at the supplier’s factory, to ensure product quality before shipping, upon delivery you may receive inferior or unacceptable goods, already paid for, and without legal recourse.
In such an event, and without proper size alignment, the supplier may not react as needed to replace the defective product in a timely manner or accept financial responsibility for the issue.
As an alternative, engage with a supplier that will share the risks. For example, we require payment for only component and materials expenditures, within 30 days after receipt, and then the remaining payment balance, within 30 days, after product acceptance by the customer.
This type of financial investment in your project will better ensure that the supplier will meet or exceed your quality expectations. In the event a quality issue should arise, you would receive full and immediate attention to the matter including full credit for defective goods, immediate execution of a recovery plan, and expedited replacement of any defective product and thus minimizing, as much as possible, the impact to you.
Stocking and Distribution:
A supplier that provides domestic product stocking, the ability to manage and coordinate all transportation from the country of origin, reconfiguration of shipments if necessary, and route directly to your intended destinations, will result in considerable savings to you.
Summary
These are considerations that are critical to the success of your product and should be seriously considered when choosing a manufacturing partner.
UMC Global provides these key functions and services, for small to medium sized OEM’s, and as a manufacturing partner we offer:
- Comprehensive project management
- Local design and engineering support
- Local PCBA assembly facility for quick turn prototypes and pre-production builds
Quality Assurance:
- All manufacturing facilities, & subcontractors, are ISO9001:2000, ISO14001,
ISO13485 and UL certified.
- Quality assurance inspection plans, tailored to the customer’s particular needs.
- In-Process inspections and testing for early detection and resolution.
- Functional Test system development and Product Performance verification.
Payment and Risk of Loss:
- Payment for only components and materials purchased for the project, within 30 days after receipt, with final payment after customer acceptance of the product.
Local Stocking and Distribution:
- Management and coordination of all transportation from country of origin, including reconfiguration of shipments if necessary, and routing to your intended destinations.
- Zero lead-time local delivery on consigned or warehoused product.
Customized Distribution/Delivery Programs that include:
- Pay-As-You-Pull Program to minimize inventory costs.
- Ship to your schedule, JIT or manual releases.

